Skip to main content
Must know
  • Needs replacing means your bank refused the card for good (it expired or was blocked). It stays saved, but no automatic payment uses it.
  • What pays instead. Your other usable card pays from now on, or you’re asked to add one. Select Make main card on it so waitlist classes are charged to it too.
  • Payment plans wait a week. A plan whose card needs replacing is held: you’re emailed “Add a card for your [club] payment plan” a week before the payment, and at that payment the plan moves to your usable card (main card first).
  • When it’s removed. A saved method is removed only when it can never be charged, such as a closed account, never by a decline alone.
What the row says. Under Payment Methods, your default card shows Main card. A card marked Needs replacing shows that badge instead. The row gives the reason (“The card has expired, so it won’t be used for automatic payments”), then what happens next: “Your Visa ending in 4242 pays from now on.” If that card isn’t your main card, it adds “Make it your main card so waitlist classes are charged to it too.” If the card pays a payment plan, the row says instead: “Your payment plan moves to your Visa ending in 4242 at its next payment.” With no other card, it reads “Add a new card and your payment plan moves to it at its next payment.” A card the payment company no longer holds, with nothing else to pay, ends “Add a new card, then remove this one.” Expired is different. A saved card past its expiry date that no charge has refused yet shows a red Expired badge. Once a charge refuses it, the badge becomes Needs replacing. A card never shows both. If a payment on a flagged card goes through, or you save the same card again, the badge clears.

Replace the card

1

Open Billing

Open Billing in the sidebar (on a phone, tap More first) and find the card marked Needs replacing.
2

Add the new card

Select Add a card on the row (Add a bank account for a bank account). The row shows it only when nothing else can pay; otherwise use Add Payment Method at the top of Payment Methods (on a phone, Add card).
3

Choose your main card

Tick or clear Make this my main card (ticked only when you have no main card or yours has expired). You see “[card] saved.” or “[card] saved as your main card.” If it couldn’t be made your main card: “[card] saved. Tap Make main card on it to use it first.”
Your new main card. If the flagged card was your main card, the new card becomes your main card either way. A flagged card is never offered Make main card. A subscription on the card. A subscription whose card needs replacing shows Change card under Subscriptions. Choose a card, then Use this card. This charges nothing now; use Pay now to pay what you owe. A declined subscription payment adds a banner at the top of Billing with Pay now and Update card (or Change card).

If a payment plan uses the card

What happens. You’re emailed “Add a card for your [club] payment plan”, and the payment isn’t tried until a week after. Then the plan moves to a saved card your club can charge. A card that expires before that payment’s date is skipped, and you’re asked to add one. What to do. On Payment Plans, the order’s button reads Add card while its card can’t be charged. A card you add there goes onto the plan at once. While your club has paused its payment plans, an order with no usable card doesn’t show Add card.

When a saved method is removed

The email. You get “Action needed: a saved payment method can no longer be charged”, with an Update your payment method link. After a returned bank debit, your subscription payments wait until you add a new method. A plan the method paid. The plan is left with no card. From the week its next payment is due, it links itself to your main saved payment method that your club can charge, with no email. You’re asked only when you have none. Payment Methods says so, and points you to Add card on the plan to choose another. Related: How does a payment plan work, and can I pay it off early? · How do I change or remove the card that pays my automatic payments? · How do I save a card or payment method? · Why am I asked to add a card for my payment plan?